Best Vocals - Beavercreek Friends
Best Choreographer - Loveland By Request
Best Combo - Loveland By Request
Best Costumes - Saint C Singers
Best show concept - Euclid Varsity Chorale
Best Crew - Solon Music In Motion
People's Choice - Olentangy Keynotes
Best Male Soloist - Pearson Bridges Marion Marding
Best Female Soloist - Avery Barnett Ross Legacy
Best Dressed director - Mr. Burke? Saint C Singers
Show Choir Spirit award - Chesterton Sandpipers
Judges award - Drummer Saint C Singers
Judges award (most memorable performance) Euclid Variety Chorale
Judges award (commanding the stage award) - Euclid Varsity Chorale opening solo dancer
Judges award (brilliant belter award) - Elgin Aquarius Soloist Bridget Bennet
Judges award (best transitions in a song) - Loveland By Request
SOLO COMP
GC Rebecca Langfield Chesterton
1RU Gabe Warner Olentangy
judges choice Delaine Harrison ETC
I’m gonna post scores because I’m guessing a lot of people are pretty interested in how things turned out how they did! I’ll be posting raw scores and ranks, but not matchups because, quite frankly, I’m still not sure I fully understand condorcet scoring yet, but I do know it’s Carmen’s new default method and it’s pretty foolproof in terms of eliminating bias! Judges will stay the same vertically. For this first post, I’m gonna do entirely raw scores cause it’s a LOT of info, and ranks will be in the next one.
RAW SCORES
Overall
Beavercreek: 225, 226, 227, 223, 221.5 | 1122.5 Total Solon: 236.5, 218, 219, 213, 222 | 1108.5 Total Loveland: 235, 233.5, 219, 221.5, 217 | 1126 Total ETC: 235, 215.5, 209.5, 219, 225 | 1104 Total Chesterton: 228, 214, 208, 220, 221.5 | 1091.5 Total Olentangy: 204, 213.5, 207, 209, 216.5 | 1050 Total
Vocals
Beavercreek: 112, 109.5, 113, 112, 112 | 558.5 Total Solon: 119.5, 108.5, 107.5 106, 109 | 550.5 Total Loveland: 117, 116, 102.5, 110, 105 | 550.5 Total ETC: 116.5, 109, 103.5, 109.5, 112.5 | 551 Total Chesterton: 111.5, 107, 104.5, 111, 111 | 545 Total Olentangy: 98.5, 105.5, 103, 104.5, 105.5 | 517 Total
Choreo
Beavercreek: 113, 116.5, 114, 111, 109.5 | 564 Total Solon: 117, 109.5, 111.5, 107, 113 | 558 Total Loveland: 118, 117.5, 116.5, 111.5, 112 | 575.5 Total ETC: 118.5, 106.5, 106, 109.5, 112.5 | 553 Total Chesterton: 116.5, 107, 103.5, 109, 110.5 | 546.5 Total Olentangy: 105.5, 108, 104, 104.5, 111 | 533 Total
I’m pretty sure I understand condorcet scoring now but correct me if I’m wrong. Like Kaitlin said earlier, it simulates every matchup possible between two groups. The victors of the matchups are determined by the judges’ ranks. Whichever group has the majority of judges put them ahead of the other group gets a point. Let’s take Solon and Loveland for example. At this point Solon and Loveland had won all the previous “matchups” simulated so this was pretty crucial. Even though Loveland had a higher score and better ranks, 3 of the 5 judges had Solon ahead of Loveland, so Solon got the point for that matchup and ended up with one point more than Loveland. Hopefully that made sense, otherwise you can go to the link Patrick provided! I also agree with Kyle, this method does a great job with evening out outlier scores and ranks!
This is a great TL;DR, Brock! Glad to see you and others are understanding the concept! If there are any other questions, check out that link under the other comment or feel free to contact me and I'll try and explain them as best as I can.
One reply for accuracy, Solon's total should be 1112 total, right? I only know because I put all of this in Excel to practice understanding the Condorcet method. Thanks for this info! So helpful to better understand
In reply for your first comment if you're looking at the raw scores above. Kyle mistyped Solon's last two scores as Loveland's last two scores. Solon's 5 scores were 236.5 | 218 | 219 | 213 | 222 totaling up to 1108.5.
In regards to your second, Condorcet is just the method used to declare placements now. Carmen allows the school to choose what they want to do. So they can choose to use raw scores, weighted scores, or borda count (rank). Marysville used borda count to check Condorcet.
EDIT: Okay wait, let me reword that. The matchup asks on a per-judge basis who beats who. Not overall. You can look at the ranks/weighted scores from Marysville and they would show the same order.
Overall rankings of the top 6 groups:
Olentangy: 10, 7, 6, 6, 6
Chesterton: 4, 6, 5, 3, 3
ETC: 3, 5, 4, 4, 1
Loveland: 2, 1, 3, 2, 5
Solon: 1, 4, 2, 5, 4
Beavercreek: 5, 2, 1, 1, 2
Rankings weren’t used to decide placements but this is all that I was given. I was told a scoring method called “Condorcet Scoring” was used to decide placements but I don’t know how it works. Perhaps someone familiar with the scoring method would like to explain!
I believe the system was based on “match ups” amount all the groups. So it would be like Beavercreek vs Solon and Beavercreek ended up winning it. In this case...
Beavercreek: 18 matchups
Solon: 17 matchups
Loveland: 16 matchups
ETC: 15 matchups
Not quite sure about Chesterton and Olentangy. It seems weird, and correct me if I’m wrong, but I think that’s how it went.
Marysville Showcase 2020
