Totino-Grace High School 1350 Gardena Avenue NE Fridley, MN 55432
|
Number of Attending Choirs:
10 Mixed Groups
4 Treble Groups
|
Event Judges:
Steven Albaugh
Gates Crisler (Critique)
Dina Else
Tim Hoffman (Instrumental)
Linda McEachran Southard
Lukas Warren (Critique)
|
All-Day:
$12 Adult
$8 Youth
Programs: $6
|
I agree with this decision. I know this was discussed on the Hastings page, but I think that all students should perform in ONLY the group they were assigned to based on auditions. Consider the following hypathetic situation...
I am a student at John doe academy(not real) and I made the junior varsity show choir. I am a sophomore, so I still have plenty of time to grow and make the varsity group, but for now, I am going to excel in my choir and hopefully dominate the junior varsity class. We arrive at our first competition of the season and I pumped, bit then I realize that there is a "jv" group competing against me that has students who were good enough to make their schools varsity group. This strips them completely of their ability to compete in exactly the same class as ours because they aren't on the same level as us given the fact that part of their choir consists of seniors who have competed at a varsity level for two years.
That sure gives them a fair shot at winning or placing as well as we would in an entire mass of competing jv kids. NOT!! I'm sorry, but I think that kids want to compete as well as "just" performing. That is what competitions are for. To mark your growth and success as a group throughout the season, and against othe choirs of your same caliber. How is a group supposed to know where they stand and how they are doing if they are randomly placed against a choir with ten varsity kids in it?
This is just my opinion and not that of my above stated affiliate choir.