Username:

 Password:

  
   
    
   







home choirs events videos choreographers arrangers costumes social songs search

 




   Participants

We do not have a list of groups that attended this event on this day.
  Show Choir Community    Events    2010 Season    Waukee Starstruck 2010
   Event Info



January 16th, 2010

Venue Info

Waukee High School
555 Southeast University Avenue
Waukee, IA 50263

Phone: (515) 987-5163

Event Details

No. of Attending Choirs:

  19 Mixed Groups
  3 Treble Groups

Hosts:

  Waukee "Millennium"
  Waukee "Spirit"

Judges:

  Heath Weber

  Tom Gerking

  Anne Chapman

  Dina Else

  Tatum Mahlen

  Mark Mangold

Tickets

Preliminary - $10
Finals - $8

Map



Waukee Starstruck 2010








Awards
 Predictions
 Photos
 Event Site
 Live Stream


   Finals

  

Groups in order of placement

 Xhilaration
 Xavier High School		Grand Champion 
Best Vocals 
Best Band 

 Central Singers, Inc.
 Davenport Central High School		First Runner Up 
Best Choreography 

 Choralation
 Valley High School		Second Runner Up 

 Rhythm in Gold
 Bloomington Kennedy High School		3rd Runner Up 

 River City Rhythm
 Muscatine High School		4th Runner Up 

 Dimensions
 Dowling Catholic High School		5th Runner Up 


   Mixed Division - Tier I (Prelims)





   Mixed Division - Tier II

  

Groups in order of performance

 Rhythm in Red

 Dallas Center-Grimes High School		Placement Unknown 

 EagleRock!

 Keota High School		Placement Unknown 


   Prep Division

  

Groups

 Xuberance
 Xavier High School		First Place 

 East Side Swingers
 Bloomington Kennedy High School		Second Place 

 Encore!
 Muscatine High School		Third Place 

 Showtime
 Iowa City West High School		4th Place 

 Blue Vibrations
 Davenport Central High School		5th Place 

 Sound Attraction
 Des Moines Lincoln High School		6th Place 

 Flip Side
 Indianola High School		7th Place 

 Company
 Lewis Central High School		8th Place 

 City Lights
 Iowa City High School		9th Place 


   Attending Members displaying 6 of 15 members (view all)  



FireCraker!





Burninthangy


Bae





EsAreUnimp...





Jorge





ShardNet



233 comments • Sort by

Prev 1 2 3 4 5 . . . 12 Next



PBhero10 • on Jan 17, 2010, 10:37 PM
Post #173
 
haha this is quite the situation now isnt it.

I also really want to know, who is right!!???



KiddZoom • on Jan 17, 2010, 10:30 PM
Post #172
 
CONUNDRUM!

Well.... which one is right?



JWill • on Jan 17, 2010, 10:23 PM
Post #171
 

that's not the "Fair Fehr" system. You look at the rankings each group receives and when there is an general agreement on placings you give it to them... For instance:

Central received 3 1's and no one topped that so they would get 1st
Xavier had 4 2's and so they'd get 2nd
Valley had 5 3's so... 3rd

then it gets trickier

Dowling got 4 6ths so they would be placed 6th
Bloomington Kennedy had 3 5th places so they would probably be placed 5th
Muscatine is left with an overall rankings that average very close to 4th 2 3 4 4 5 5

with the FF system you'd get Central, Xavier, Valley, Muscatine, Kennedy, Dowling (although Muscatine and Kennedy were SUPER close in pretty much every way you look at it)


You're wrong. Under the Fehr Fair system Xavier would have won. The FF system is based on majority voting. Central got 3 out of 6 first place votes, which is not a majority. Therefore you go to the next step, compare Central and Xavier alone, and 3 judges have Xavier before Central. Tied. Therefore go to the next step, look at both first and second place votes. All 6 judges had Xavier in first or second, only 3 judges had Central in first or second, therefore Xavier wins.



Rian • on Jan 17, 2010, 10:05 PM
Post #170
 

that's not the "Fair Fehr" system. You look at the rankings each group receives and when there is an general agreement on placings you give it to them... For instance:

Central received 3 1's and no one topped that so they would get 1st
Xavier had 4 2's and so they'd get 2nd
Valley had 5 3's so... 3rd

then it gets trickier

Dowling got 4 6ths so they would be placed 6th
Bloomington Kennedy had 3 5th places so they would probably be placed 5th
Muscatine is left with an overall rankings that average very close to 4th 2 3 4 4 5 5

with the FF system you'd get Central, Xavier, Valley, Muscatine, Kennedy, Dowling (although Muscatine and Kennedy were SUPER close in pretty much every way you look at it)


Thanks for the brush up, Jay .



Rian • on Jan 17, 2010, 10:02 PM
Post #169
 

That is Olympic Scoring.

That's right, My apologies.



Jorge • on Jan 17, 2010, 10:02 PM
Post #168
 
Congrats to everyone who competed here! I have heard great things about many groups and shows! Also so proud of Bloomington Kennedy- can't wait to rehearse with you guys on Monday

Also, congrats to Muscatine, its such an honor to choreograph you and thanks for pushing yourselves in our rehearsal on Friday, this just proves hard work and determination pay off!

So great to hear so many wonderful comments about Muscatine's opener!

Yeah everyone... our opener would not be half as great without the wonderful choreography by Mr. Kevin Chase. Thanks again Kevin! See you in what... 5 days? haha

K

KC • on Jan 17, 2010, 9:55 PM
Post #167
 
Congrats to everyone who competed here! I have heard great things about many groups and shows! Also so proud of Bloomington Kennedy- can't wait to rehearse with you guys on Monday

Also, congrats to Muscatine, its such an honor to choreograph you and thanks for pushing yourselves in our rehearsal on Friday, this just proves hard work and determination pay off!

So great to hear so many wonderful comments about Muscatine's opener!



Jorge • on Jan 17, 2010, 9:49 PM
Post #166
 
Dropping the highest and lowest scores...

That is Olympic Scoring.



juliofrommississippi • on Jan 17, 2010, 9:46 PM
Post #165
 
Dropping the highest and lowest scores...

that's not the "Fair Fehr" system. You look at the rankings each group receives and when there is an general agreement on placings you give it to them... For instance:

Central received 3 1's and no one topped that so they would get 1st
Xavier had 4 2's and so they'd get 2nd
Valley had 5 3's so... 3rd

then it gets trickier

Dowling got 4 6ths so they would be placed 6th
Bloomington Kennedy had 3 5th places so they would probably be placed 5th
Muscatine is left with an overall rankings that average very close to 4th 2 3 4 4 5 5

with the FF system you'd get Central, Xavier, Valley, Muscatine, Kennedy, Dowling (although Muscatine and Kennedy were SUPER close in pretty much every way you look at it)



EsAreUnimportant • on Jan 17, 2010, 9:38 PM
Post #164
 
You will never hear me say this again.... But maybe the "Fair Fehr" system would've have been better to use here.

This competition is interesting because it's not a typical "one judge ruining everything" outcome. What I mean by that is it's not as if a group received 111116 rankings. Also, it's not simply one group that has "interesting" results. Muscatine was placed from 2nd to 5th... Bloomington Kennedy from 1st to 5th... and of course Davenport Central from 1st to 6th. I think this shows that each judge had a different idea of what they wanted, and that all of these groups in finals at Waukee were truly in the running.

I think we're too used to there being clear delinations between groups at competitions. Sometimes it just isn't so, and I think that these results illustrate that.



Rian • on Jan 17, 2010, 9:36 PM
Post #163
 
Dropping the highest and lowest scores...



Jimtron3000 • on Jan 17, 2010, 9:33 PM
Post #162
 
You will never hear me say this again.... But maybe the "Fair Fehr" system would've have been better to use here.


Whats that?



juliofrommississippi • on Jan 17, 2010, 9:31 PM
Post #161
 
You will never hear me say this again.... But maybe the "Fair Fehr" system would've have been better to use here.



Jorge • on Jan 17, 2010, 9:30 PM
Post #160
 
It was all over the place. The one judge who had us 8th in the day had us 4th at night. haha



EsAreUnimportant • on Jan 17, 2010, 9:29 PM
Post #159
 
The only groups that seem to be remotely consistent in those rankings are Xavier and Valley. Everyone else has a range of at least three placements... or, in CSI's case, six! Very close competition



Bae • on Jan 17, 2010, 9:12 PM
Post #158
 
Wow. The scores for us, Muscatine, and Bloomington Kennedy are so incredibly jumbled. I hope I find out soon why Tom Gerking and Kevin(?) ManGold weren't big fans of our show, so that way we can make it so they will like it



juliofrommississippi • on Jan 17, 2010, 9:11 PM
Post #157
 
Wow... that is some kind of messed up....

Central gets 3 1sts and 2 6ths???? It's not surprising that the two 6th places came from two judges who I have found to be sorta incompetent over the years...



PBhero10 • on Jan 17, 2010, 9:06 PM
Post #156
 
Here are two videos I shot at Waukee...

West Des Moines Valley "Disco Heaven/ Boom Boom Pow/ Let's Dance"

Xavier "The Old Red Hills Of Home"


Hey thanks for putting these up.



ShardNet • on Jan 17, 2010, 8:14 PM
Post #155
 
FINALS-

Chapman-
1st- Davenport Central
2nd- Xavier
3rd- West Des Moines Valley
4th- Bloomington Kennedy
5th- Muscatine
6th- Dowling Catholic

Else-
1st- Davenport Central
2nd- Xavier
3rd- Muscatine
4th- West Des Moines Valley
5th- Bloomington Kennedy
6th- Dowling Catholic

Mahlen-
1st- Bloomington Kennedy
2nd- Xavier
3rd- West Des Moines Valley
4th- Davenport Central
5th- Muscatine
6th- Dowling Catholic

ManGold-
1st- Xavier
2nd- Bloomington Kennedy
3rd- West Des Moines Valley
4th- Muscatine
5th- Dowling Catholic
6th- Davenport Central

Weber-
1st- Davenport Central
2nd- Xavier
3rd- West Des Moines Valley
4th- Muscatine
5th- Bloomington Kennedy
6th- Dowling Catholic

Gerking-
1st- Xavier
2nd- Muscatine
3rd- West Des Moines Valley
4th- Dowling Catholic
5th- Bloomington Kennedy
6th- Davenport Central


Yikes, very close, but everyone knew going into finals that this one could've gone either way.



Jorge • on Jan 17, 2010, 7:33 PM
Post #154
 
Here are two videos I shot at Waukee...

West Des Moines Valley "Disco Heaven/ Boom Boom Pow/ Let's Dance"

Xavier "The Old Red Hills Of Home"


Prev 1 2 3 4 5 . . . 12 Next


Sponsored






©2002-2024 Show Choir Community. All Rights Reserved.